Wired News: Recycling Program a Tough Cell.
This story is a great example of awful journalism. At its core, it's reporting two facts:
- cell phones recycled at places like Staples may be reused or resold instead of recycled into component parts
- the people doing this might make some money while they're doing it
However, those core facts are dressed up in a whole lot of "OH MY GOD! LIES! LIES! THESE PHONES AREN'T REALLY BEING RECYCLED, THOSE DIRTY CAPITALISTS!" Which is just irresponsible. Because (a) it's a heck of a lot more efficient to re-use something than to recycle it, and (b) who cares if these guys make money? They're providing a valuable service: they're keeping the toxic bombs that are our little electronic gizmos out of the ground for another few years, and maybe preventing more from being made.
There is one good point hidden among all the dross: they do point out that these refurbed phones are being injected into third world countries that have even crummier recycling infrastructures then we do. But the reality is that, in the US, most people would just throw the damn things away if this service wasn't provided. And if you throw it away, you've just bypassed that nice recycling infrastructure.
Update: It's important to point out that an even better option for recycling your old phone is to donate it so that it can be reprogrammed to dial 911 and be handed out by battered women's shelters as emergency beacons. I wish I could find a link for this, so if any faithful readers have one, please place it in the comments.
Update updated: Skye points out The Wireless Foundation. Yay Skye! 10:17:15 AM ()
|
|